











|
| Cements & Glues |
 |
| This is a Thread form
the Hobby Talk forum about adhesives. |
Ok, I've got a question.
I've read that styrene glue is better than Super glue on styrene
models. Due to the fact that it melts the plastic together
and forms little beads where the glue is that helps with the
seam filling. How long does it take the styrene glue to
"totally cure" before it is safe to sand?? Most of the
time I use super glue because it does not take long for it to
dry therefore sanding can be done almost immediately afterward.
Is styrene glue better than super glue??
|
No glue expert here, but I experimented with
CAs and went happily back to styrene glue. CAs have no wiggle
time for adjusting and aligning, and glues made for styrene will
take more pressure without snapping back apart. Don't know
cure time, as there's usually enough to do on other areas before
continuing on with a subassembly, giving each bit plenty of time
to cure.
Have you tried the stuff like Ambroid Pro Weld?
dreamer
|
Normal Testors glue, both liquid and tube,
give it a full day before you start sanding.
There is another liquid plastic cement called
Tenax 7R that sets up in just a few minutes. I have a
friend who swears by it. You can sand almost immediately.
The problem I have with it is that it evaporates VERY fast, so
you really can't do any big seams with it. Like, by the
time you've brushed it on a whole fuselage, it dries before you
can get the fuselage halves together. I'm told it's best
used by holding parts together and using the brush to let the
glue "bleed" into the seam by capillary action. I have yet
to master that. But it IS great on smaller models with
smaller joining seams.
John P
|
I use Testors and Tenax... for different
things. If I have a seam to put together (like 2 halves of
a fuselage) I use Tenax. I use a capillary applicator;
start at the place where the parts fit best. I do just a
couple of inches (or less) and let it set, then do a little
more, and let it set. It takes a while to get the whole
thing done, but I only have to aline one small section at a
time, so I end up with a very good fit all the way around.
Since Tenax creeps thru a joint, the parts
are best glued when they are already together, so this approach
works well... requires little if any clamping... and makes it
easier to get it lined up properly all the way around.
Tenax does evaporate very quickly, so you
lose a lot of it before you even use it... make sure you have a
good supply!
If I have a smaller contact point (like
landing gear) I use Testors tube glue for more control.
And I use AC where I am connecting different materials, or have
tiny contact point... like putting on spark plug wires.
They all have advantages... and I am sure
that with practice they all wok equally well. One big
difference though... for Testors & Tenax, I allow at least 6-8
hours before sanding (12-24 is better) but with CA you want to
sand it soon, because it will get hard and harder with time.
naplak
|
That's the way I've been doing it for years
and it's the ONLY way I ever join fuselage halves. I'm
surprised that you say you haven't mastered it because it's not
hard and, having seen your work, you're abilities are quite
obviously above average.
I apply it with a long, thin, soft artists
brush.
It makes lining up seams significantly
easier. My standard method is to start at the tail of the
plane. I will usually use tube glue on the fin/rudder
because they have flat, broad mating surfaces. After
gluing the fin, I hold it with tape and start on the fuselage.
That's where the advantage of applying liquid cement to the seam
with capillary action is ideal. You can line up a small
portion of the seam to perfection (say the seam from the rear of
the cockpit to the vertical fin) and then apply the cement.
You don't have to worry about what's happening on any part of
the fuselage seam. Just get those few inches perfect.
Then do the same thing on the bottom (maybe from the rear of the
wing root to the tail). By doing a few inches at a time,
you can get each section of seam perfect.
That might not be critical if you're doing a
Tamiya kit where everything lines up perfectly to start with.
You can put thicker cement on the seam and be reasonably assured
that everything will line up just fines when you join the
halves. But if you're a poor boy like me building kits
from old monogram molds (like the Voodoo), doing the seams a few
inches at a time is big help. I put that Voodoo fuselage
together with liquid cement and polished away the seam to
invisibility without a drop of filler.
BTW, Just last night, I was test fitting the
fuselage on my AMT B-52G. OY! I dare anybody to put
tube glue on those seams and line it up within 3 HOURS!
TO THE ORIGINAL QUESTION: Styrene cement is
preferred when practical. I use CA for joining some
smaller components when it's not practical to use regular glue
(i.e. attaching landing gear doors, antennae, missiles).
But styrene glue is definitely stronger in the long term.
Brent G.
|
Another liquid cement that works about as
well as the Tenax 7R is Plastruct Bondene, and it has the
advantage of being about half the price of the Tenax.
Tenax/Plastruct can also be used as an accelerant to the Testors
tube glue. Just use the tube stuff as you normally would,
when everything’s in position, apply the liquid over it and hold
a few moments. Instead of waiting a day, the seam can be worked
in a few hours.
renegade
|
I only just started using
Tenax recently, Brent, give me time. It's hard to break
the old habit of applying it to both seams before joining the
halves. I find it hard to believe one can "bleed" enough
glue into a seam to hold it well.
I did use Tenax to glue
the Trumpeter F-107 fuselage together. One thing I love
about it its sandability in seams. Tube glue often seams
to sand differently than the surrounding plastic, leaving a
slightly visible seam. Tenax doesn't do that, and now I know
why.
John P.
|
Ah...therein lies the difference between
liquid cements and most other products (under the generic
umbrella of "glue").
Many products create a bond that's primarily
chemical. CA is the best example of this. Epoxy is
another obvious example. Also included are any of the
various wood glues (although people don't use Elmer's for
plastic models...well, except on the clear parts). And, to
a lesser (but still measurable) degree, it also applies to the
thicker "tube" type glue we use on plastic. This generally
has a filler not chemically unlike celluloid. These glues
all add a third agent in the seam to hold the parts together.
Liquid cements of the Tenax type create a
mechanical bond. They are not designed to remain in the
seam or become part of the joint. They are designed to
dissolve the plastic and then evaporate. It's analogous to
welding...two components "melt" together with no third agent
binding them.
So you don't have to get enough glue into the
seam to hold it. You only have to get enough glue into the
seam to dissolve the plastic for a few seconds.
Brent G
ed.note... to recap, a "glue"
remains in the joint to bond, a "cement" causes the materials to
weld together
|
For your run of the mill
styrene kit I usually use Testors styrene glue in the triangular
bottle with the needle nose applicator. But there are
times when you have to pre-paint a part before assembling...such
as the Land of the Giants Snake Scene. The mouth is best
assembled and painted before 'trapping' it inside the two head
halves and here is where regular styrene just didn't seem to
want to bond a painted surface to an unpainted one. My
solution was to use Super Glue Gel. The Gel bonds
the two surfaces together but doesn't dry as fast as regular
super glue and gives you ample "play" time when
aligning/adjusting.
Mark S.
|
I use both types, but
found Tenax very useful. I tried dipping my #11 blade into
the stuff and applying it that way. It goes right where you want
it, not too much and can get into those fine cracks that need
just a little. It may take a little longer, but no fuss or
muss. Just be careful that you don't get too much Tenax on
your blade.
Ken M.
|
|
 |
| |
|